ITGC Audit: Automated vs. Manual

The Future of ITGC Audit: Automated vs. Manual

Ronan Grobler

Senior GRC Manager

Linkedin

If you’re still doing ITGC audits manually, it’s time to rethink your approach. Many industries have already embraced automation to streamline operations, and IT audits are the next frontier. But what are the real benefits, and is it worth making the switch?

Let’s dive into the key differences between automated and manual ITGC auditing processes, explore the many advantages of compliance automation software, and most importantly, show you why it could be the answer your business has been looking for.

TL;DR: Automated vs. Manual ITGC Audits

  • Compliance automation software makes ITGC audits faster, more accurate, and hassle-free compared to manual processes.
  • Automated systems provide daily, continuous monitoring while manual audits only occur twice a year.
  • With Scytale’s AI-powered automation platform, you get full-time visibility and 100% coverage, eliminating the risks of missed deficiencies.
  • Data extraction and consolidation are automated for speed, accuracy, and reduced human error.
  • Real-time collaboration replaces time-consuming, error-prone manual review processes.

The Benefits of Switching to Automated ITGC Audits: A Smarter, Faster Approach for Your Business

When it comes to ITGC audits, security compliance automation is changing the game. Gone are the days of relying on outdated manual processes that leave room for human errors and inefficiencies. 

With automation, you can continuously monitor and audit your IT General Controls (ITGC) around the clock, ensuring your business runs its GRC program efficiently and stays SOX compliant effortlessly. Let’s explore how automation can elevate your compliance processes.

AspectAutomatedManual
MonitoringDaily Monitoring (365 Days a Year)2 Times a Year
Population Coverage100% CoverageStatistical Sample (25-40)
Data ExtractionFully AutomatedManual Process
Data ConsolidationStreamlined & FastManual & Tedious
Working PapersAuto-GeneratedManually Prepared
Findings IdentificationInstant DetectionManual & Inconsistent
Review ProcessVia Platform (Real-Time Collaboration)Via Email (Back-and-Forth)

1. Monitoring: Always On vs. Twice a Year

  • Automated: Daily Monitoring
  • Manual: Biannual Monitoring

With automation, you’re getting continuous controls monitoring, meaning issues are spotted and addressed right away, 365 days a year. This keeps deficiencies in check and allows for quicker responses to any problems. Think of it like having a watchdog on duty all year long. On the flip side, manual audits happen just twice a year, which means potential issues could slip through the cracks and not be caught until it’s too late.

2. Population Coverage: Every Single Data Point vs. Sampling

  • Automated: 100% Coverage
  • Manual: Statistical Sample (25-40)

Automation takes a comprehensive approach by reviewing every single data point, leaving no room for missed deficiencies. This means you get a complete and accurate picture of your IT controls. Manual audits, however, rely on sampling – a small portion of your data – so there’s always the risk that something important gets overlooked.

3. Data Extraction: Smooth and Fast vs. Slow and Risky

  • Automated: Fully Automated
  • Manual: Manual Process

Data extraction with automation is seamless and doesn’t require any human intervention. Our comprehensive compliance automation platform takes care of the heavy lifting, letting you focus on the more important tasks, like addressing any issues that are flagged. With manual audits, however, the process is much slower and prone to human error, which increases the likelihood of missing critical deficiencies.

GET COMPLIANT 90% FASTER WITH AUTOMATION

Scytale badges

4. Data Consolidation: Effortless vs. Time-Consuming

  • Automated: Streamlined and Fast
  • Manual: Manual and Tedious

Automated systems consolidate data quickly and efficiently, making it ready for the audit in no time. Manual consolidation, however, is often time-consuming and complicated, requiring cross-referencing and validation to ensure accuracy. Automation cuts out the hassle and saves you valuable time.

5. Working Papers: Instant Access vs. Slow Preparation

  • Automated: Auto-Generated
  • Manual: Manually Prepared

In automated systems, working papers are generated automatically, meaning you get instant access to everything you need for your audit. With manual processes, however, preparing these documents takes time and can lead to delays, impacting your overall timeline.

6. Findings Identification: Fast and Accurate vs. Slow and Error-Prone

  • Automated: Instant Detection
  • Manual: Manual and Inconsistent

Automated systems use advanced algorithms to instantly detect any deficiencies, ensuring that issues are caught early. Manual methods, on the other hand, are slow and less reliable, often requiring repetitive tasks that can lead to missed findings.

7. Review Process: Real-Time Collaboration vs. Email Back-and-Forth

  • Automated: Via Platform
  • Manual: Via Email

With automation, the review process takes place on a dedicated platform that allows for real-time collaboration and approval workflows. In manual processes, reviews are often done through email, which can lead to confusion, delays, and miscommunication. Compliance automation tools streamline the entire process, making it quicker and more efficient.

The Importance of Effective IT General Controls for SOX Compliance

To achieve and maintain SOX compliance, having proper IT General Controls (ITGC) in place is essential. ITGCs are fundamental for ensuring the accuracy, reliability, and security of financial reporting, which is critical to meet SOX requirements. Without strong ITGCs, organizations risk exposing sensitive data, leading to potential compliance issues, financial discrepancies, or even security breaches.

Automating ITGC audits makes it easier to ensure that these controls are consistently enforced and maintained. Scytale’s platform not only helps identify deficiencies but also ensures continuous monitoring of ITGCs, allowing businesses to respond quickly to any potential issues. This proactive approach helps keep your business in a steady state of compliance, reducing the risk of penalties or damage to your organization’s reputation.

Here are some of the key reasons why effective ITGCs are crucial for SOX compliance:

Why IT General Controls (ITGC) Matter for SOX Compliance
  • Accuracy of Financial Reporting: Strong ITGCs ensure that data used in financial reports is accurate and reliable.
  • Data Protection: Proper controls safeguard sensitive information and help prevent breaches or fraud.
  • Operational Efficiency: Effective ITGCs streamline business processes, making compliance audits smoother and faster.
  • Risk Management: Identifying potential security vulnerabilities early reduces the likelihood of compliance violations or security incidents.

The table below outlines the key differences between automated and manual ITGC audits for SOX compliance:

BenefitAutomated ITGC AuditsManual ITGC Audits
Monitoring FrequencyDaily (365 days a year)Twice a year (Biannual)
Coverage100% of the populationSmall statistical sample
Data AccuracyReal-time, automated detectionProne to human error
Audit SpeedFast, real-time updatesTime-consuming and slow
Compliance ConsistencyContinuous, always-on monitoringInconsistent, limited review
Risk DetectionImmediate, proactiveDelayed and reactive

By automating your ITGC audits with Scytale, you’re not only improving the efficiency of your compliance processes but also taking the vital steps necessary to ensure the integrity and security of your financial and IT systems, forming the foundation for successful SOX compliance.

Streamlining ITGC Audits with Scytale

The difference between automated and manual ITGC auditing processes is clear: automation wins hands down. With Scytale’s AI-powered compliance automation platform, you get 24/7 deficiencies monitoring, full coverage, automatically generated working papers, access management, risk assessment and remediation, your very own SOX ITGC expert, and much more – making audits faster, more accurate, and hassle-free.

By adopting automation, your team can move away from time-consuming manual tasks and focus on strategic improvements and business growth, ultimately strengthening your IT controls and ensuring your business stays audit-ready around the clock. 

While manual methods may have their place, the future of ITGC audits undoubtedly lies in automation. It makes SOX compliance faster, simpler, and far more efficient, all while empowering your team to make smarter, more impactful decisions for your organization. Let Scytale help you streamline your SOX ITGC audits and maintain compliance with ease.

FAQs about ITGC Audits

What does ITGC mean in audit?

ITGC stands for Information Technology General Controls. These are key controls that ensure the integrity and security of data in an organization’s IT systems. ITGC audits assess the effectiveness of these controls in meeting security, compliance, and operational requirements.

What are some ways you can automate IT audits and assessments?

Automating IT audits involves using software platforms like Scytale that continuously monitor IT systems, handle data extraction and consolidation, and automatically generate reports. These platforms also use AI to detect deficiencies and ensure compliance with key standards like the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) or the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

How does automation improve SOX compliance?

Automation enhances SOX compliance by providing continuous monitoring, accurate data processing, and faster identification of control deficiencies. It reduces human errors, streamlines audit processes, and ensures that businesses remain compliant with SOX requirements year-round.

Why is ITGC important for SOX compliance?

ITGC is crucial for SOX compliance because it ensures the reliability and security of financial reporting. Strong ITGC helps organizations maintain accurate financial statements and protect against data breaches or fraud, which is required for SOX compliance.

How can Scytale help with ITGC audits?

Scytale’s AI-powered platform automates the entire ITGC audit process, from continuous monitoring to generating audit evidence and working papers. It ensures full coverage, quicker identification of issues, and greater accuracy, helping businesses streamline their audits and maintain SOX compliance. Plus, businesses also get the added advantage of a dedicated team of GRC experts and Scy, our next-gen GRC-savvy AI Agent, to support you every step of the way on your compliance journey.

Ronan Grobler

Ronan Grobler

As a Senior GRC Manager at Scytale, Ronan Grobler leads a team of experts helping companies meet top security and privacy standards like ISO 27001, ISO 9001, ISO 42001, SOC 1, SOC 2, GDPR, HIPAA, CCPA, and DORA. With over four years of experience in governance, risk, and compliance, Ronan has supported businesses of all sizes - from... Read more